The Riley Athletic Hall of Fame was started in 1988. Below are the Members and the years they were inducted.
| Class of 2006 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Greg Carroll | 1992 |
| Sandra (Jerzak) Dobosiewicz | 1987 |
| Tom Metcalfe | Coach |
| Michael Poole | 1981 |
| Brian Stultz | 1996 |
| Lisa (Engdahl) Suter | 1982 |
| Dr. Ann (Allen) Symonds | 1976 |
| Kim (Wilson) Williams | 1994 |
| Class of 2004 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Paul Bowers | 1952 |
| Angela Boykins | 1983 |
| Ed Filer | 1982 |
| Sam Henderson | 1981 |
| Lisa Jackowiak | 1986 |
| Larry Morningstar | Coach |
| Tom O’Niell | 1985 |
| Kenneth Reynolds | 1971 |
| Ken Sult | 1950 |
| Rico Swanson | 1993 |
| John “Jack” Swantz | 1940 |
| Dr. Mark Toth | 1965 |
| Class of 2002 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Teri Carlton-Woodruff | 1978 |
| Terry Crone | 1970 |
| Kurt Frazier | 1985 |
| Dick Geraghty | 1950 |
| Dave Gleason | 1959 |
| Jeff Katona | 1984 |
| Sheryl Lynch-Sireakowski | 1988 |
| Al Lusk | 1982 |
| Steve Nadolny | 1975 |
| Andre Owens | 1991 |
| Steve Reygaert | 1982 |
| Jeermal Sylvester | 1990 |
| Matt Willis | 1991 |
| Class of 2000 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Don Barnbrook | Coach |
| Ron Bella | 1952 |
| Bob Berger | Coach |
| William Stephan Black II | 1986 |
| Raymond Bubick | 1950 |
| Mary Freitag | 1977 |
| Larry Dean Hostetler | 1961 |
| James J. Krider | 1950 |
| Richard Morrison | 1945 |
| Andrew Nemeth | 1963 |
| Ralph Pieniazkiewicz Jr. | 1984 |
| Brad Toothaker | 1987 |
| Derrick Wesley | 1984 |
| Class of 1998 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Dave Dunlap | Coach |
| Art Floran | 1960 |
| Craig Frazier | 1947 |
| Paul Frazier | 1947 |
| Wally Gartee | Coach |
| Eugene Kuzmic | 1950 |
| Algie Oldham | Principal |
| Kandis Perry | 1984 |
| Nancy Scales-Simon | 1982 |
| Vince Shelton | 1978 |
| Robert Taylor | 1952 |
| Forrest Wood | Coach |
| Richard Wood | 1945 |
| Class of 1995 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Cindy Alveare | 1979 |
| Gary Croone | 1972 |
| Gary Ellis | 1974 |
| Albert David Filer IV | 1979 |
| Dennis Floden | 1958 |
| Robert Foster | 1969 |
| Lori Garbacz | 1976 |
| Jack Hildebrand | |
| Jack Jessup | 1936 |
| Mark McCoy | 1951 |
| Dale McDaniel | 1942 |
| Robert Smith | |
| Mike Szucs | 1965 |
| Class of 1994 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| John E. Byers Sr. | 1993 |
| Margaret Kinerk | Coach |
| Leonard Smorin | 1950 |
| Robert D. Lee | 1957 |
| Jim Jewell | 1962 |
| Norman McDaniel | 1940 |
| Rudolph Barkovich | 1933 |
| Brian LeWallen | 1966 |
| Jim Altec | 1951 |
| Esther Robinson | Honoraree Inductee |
| Class of 1992 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Harold Brazier | 1973 |
| Richard Fetters | Coach |
| Nick Garbacz | 1934 |
| Steve Herczeg | 1950 |
| Larry Katz | 1963 |
| John M. Kudlaty | 1955 |
| Beverly Lincoln | 1963 |
| Fred Odusch | 1955 |
| John Odusch | 1958 |
| Kevin Powers | 1968 |
| Andy Tompos | 1947 |
| Victor Wukovits | 1936 |
| Tom Wukovits | 1934 |
| Class of 1990 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| Bill Berta | 1937 |
| Terry Beyer | 1957 |
| John Buchanon | 1958 |
| Owen “Dippy” Evans | 1939 |
| Robert Gordes | 1966 |
| Bob Hartman | 1946 |
| Steve Horvath | 1939 |
| Steve Nemeth | 1942 |
| Bob Rush | 1944 |
| Joe Schafer | Coach |
| Jim Whitmer | 1948 |
| Bob Whitmer | 1945 |
| Class of 1988 | |
| Name | Year Graduated |
| John Abell | 1954 |
| Joe Domnanovich | 1937 |
| John Galloway | 1966 |
| Dick Good | 1938 |
| David Hendrix | 1962 |
| Paul Kelly | Coach |
| Fred Kotzenmacher | 1932 |
| Ernest Kovatch | 1945 |
| Joe Kubarich | 1934 |
| Eldon Motts | 1952 |
| Ross Stephenson | 1939 |
| Wayne Wakefield | Coach |
| E.G. White Jr. | 1966 |